Blog Global · AI & search

Google is answering more questions itself. Is your website ready?

AI Overviews now take a large share of the clicks that used to go to websites. Here's what the research shows, which businesses are hit hardest, and what to change.

Binary Quotes team13 November 20264 min read

If your traffic from Google has gone soft over the past year and you couldn't work out why, you're not imagining it.

Google now puts an AI-written answer at the top of many searches. These AI Overviews are handy for searchers. For the businesses whose pages they draw on, they're a problem: people get what they need without ever clicking through.

What the numbers say

Two studies are worth knowing about, because they measure this in very different ways and end up in the same place.

58%
fewer clicks for the top-ranking page when an AI Overview appears, comparing December 2023 with December 2025.Source: Ahrefs, 300,000 keywords

Ahrefs looked at 300,000 keywords, half with AI Overviews and half without, using real Search Console click data. When it first ran the study in April 2025, the gap was 34.5%. Re-run with December 2025 data, the top result was getting 58% fewer clicks than it otherwise would have. Even the page in position two lost about half its clicks.

Pew Research Center took a different route. It tracked the actual browsing of 900 US adults through March 2025. When a Google search showed an AI summary, people clicked a regular result on 8% of visits. Without a summary, it was 15%. Only 1% of visits involved clicking a link inside the summary itself, and people were more likely to end their browsing session altogether: 26% of the time, against 16%.

Google disputes this. It called Pew's methodology flawed and says it hasn't seen significant drops in total traffic to the web. Both can be true at once: overall clicks across the web can hold up while particular kinds of page lose a lot.

Which searches are hit hardest

In Ahrefs' data, 99.2% of keywords that trigger an AI Overview are informational: “how do I”, “what is”, “best way to”. That's exactly the kind of search many small businesses wrote blog posts to rank for.

Searches for a specific business, or by someone ready to buy or book, are a different story. “Shopify designer for jewellery brands in Dublin” still sends people to websites. So does your business name.

In practice, the old plan of publishing lots of how-to articles to pull in traffic is weaker than it was. The people who do arrive are more likely to be interested already, which makes your website's job of turning them into enquiries matter more.

Fewer visitors, but worth more

There's some good news in here. Semrush found that visitors who arrive from AI tools such as ChatGPT convert at 4.4 times the rate of the average organic search visitor. It's a single study, measured on conversion rate alone, so treat the exact figure with care. It does match what we see: someone who has asked an AI to compare options and then clicks through to you has done most of their research.

Semrush also expects visitors from AI search to overtake those from traditional search by 2028. Whether or not that date holds, it's the direction of travel.

What we'd do about it

  1. Say plainly what you do, for whom, and whereAI tools build their answers from clear statements. A homepage that says “we craft digital experiences” gives them nothing to work with. “We design Shopify stores for jewellery brands in the UK and Ireland” does.
  2. Answer real questions on your own pagesPut honest answers to the questions customers actually ask on your service pages: price ranges, timelines, what's included. Add FAQ and organisation structured data so search engines can read it reliably.
  3. Make your name worth searching forSearches for your brand are the ones AI doesn't swallow. Google reviews, a complete Business Profile and mentions on sites your customers trust all build the demand that sends people straight to you.
  4. Treat every visitor as harder-wonIf fewer people arrive, each one counts for more. Fast pages, one clear message, proof right where people hesitate, and an obvious next step. This is where most small-business sites quietly lose people.
  5. Measure enquiries, not trafficSet up analytics to show visits from chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai, copilot.microsoft.com and gemini.google.com separately. Judge the site on calls booked and forms sent, not on sessions.

The short version

Search isn't dying, but the deal has changed. Google keeps more of the clicks for simple questions. The businesses that do well from here will be the ones that are easy to understand, easy to find by name, and easy to choose once someone lands on the site.

Sources

  1. Ahrefs: AI Overviews reduce clicks (original study, April 2025)
  2. Ahrefs via Business Wire: AI Overviews now cost websites 58% of their clicks (May 2026)
  3. Pew Research Center: Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears (July 2025)
  4. Search Engine Roundtable: Pew study and Google's response
  5. Semrush: AI search and SEO traffic study (July 2025)
Written by the Binary Quotes team in Gurugram. We design brands, websites and online stores for founders in India, the UK, Europe and Asia.

Want to know where your website stands?

Request a free website review, or book a 30-minute call with Vaishali. Either way, you'll leave with clear priorities for your website.